06 November 2019

Solovyov and the problem of the (post-)sæcular


Over at The Dorothy Option I recently wrote a guest post critiquing the political doctrine of intégrisme slightly (and I do mean that; the true point of difference I have with Josias-form intégrisme is embedded in the third sentence) from its left, borrowing in particular from the theopolitical themes of Dostoevsky and The Brothers Karamazov. The central point, I hope, is clear. Post-liberalism either will become, or already is, a semi-permanent feature of our current blown-apart political life. We can see this given the rise of various nationalisms, populisms, fundamentalisms and cults of personality throughout the world. Given even the recent history of illiberal ideologies in the twentieth century, mistakes in articulation can prove to be enormously costly: not just in terms of body count, but in terms of our collective and individual souls.

This, and this alone, has been my concern in writing about intégrisme so critically. Particularly because I share so many of intégrisme’s concerns about the inward falsity of liberalism – namely, that individual human projects and destinies are not so easily disentangled from public life; and that both the material and intellectual-emotional concerns of people are wrapped up in questions of policy in an intimate and messy way – at one point I came very close to an intégriste position. This position was challenged by life. I became intimately involved in communities – the Antiochian Church in particular; but also Saimasai, which included both Russian Orthodox and Hanafî Sunnî Muslims – that had been subject to religious persecution by illiberal régimes whose theopolitical vision was not entirely unlike the intégriste one.

And yet, these communities themselves were not liberal. Despite a certain degree of commitment to pluralism and tolerance of beliefs in tension with each other, the community in Saimasai was in many ways deeply traditionalist. On questions of gender rôles, sexual ethics more generally, dress, hospitality ethics, insider-outsider distinctions, trust of religious authorities, relationship with the state – Saimasai was markedly different from the standard American conception of the public space. I found the same thing quite true with the Antiochian Church in Pawtucket. Despite it being a very American immigrant community, and despite their being open and welcoming beyond my wildest expectations to an outsider like me, the internal norms among the parishioners were very different from my Anglo, crypto-Quaker upbringing. Again, at Saint Mary’s there were very different, and far more traditional, norms regarding family obligations, sexual ethics, hospitality and politics.

The history of these communities has also affected my thinking. All three of the præ-Soviet, Soviet and post-Soviet histories of the Qazaq people and of Kazakhstan generally have impressed on me the precariousness of the hard-won (and sometimes not-so-stable, riddled with tensions and bigotries) modus vivendi between Russian and Qazaq there. That’s not something to be lightly brushed aside.

The same feeling holds true with my second-hand experience of Arab nationalism. (I was in the same parish as Michel ‘Aflaq’s niece. Listening carefully, I did notice that several of the parishioners had ties to or sympathies with the SSNP, the PFLP or the Ba‘th Party. One could say I absorbed much of my sympathy for Arab nationalism by osmosis.) For a long time Arab nationalism was the only viable way in which Christians in the Middle East could participate in public life without either: adopting Ottomanist mannerisms; affecting an outward passivity in the face of Islâmic dominance; or resorting to preëmptive sectarian violence. On the negative side, the options available to the Orthodox Christian communities of Palestine, Syria and Ægypt were remarkably limited; on the positive side, even nationalists who were not Christian understood the overlap between Christian concerns and Arabist ones in the Middle East.

These and several other observations from my life in China both impressed on me the dangerous fallacies of liberalism in its attempts to circumscribe and flatten the deep community lives I witnessed, and also the equal danger of ‘flattening’ that life in the other direction by yoking state and Church (or state and mosque) into a master-slave dialectic. Deep-reading Russian, Arabic and Qazaq history and political philosophy – along with Orthodox theology – has put me on a very difficult tightrope to walk: a tightrope that, granted, involves reappropriating some aspects of socialism and even Marxism into my worldview.

But walking that tightrope is necessary for a Christian to do, because to do otherwise is to court (self-)deception and the temptations of ideological idolatry. In following Christ, no Christian should put themselves into an easy alliance with Pilate and Herod, and reach gladly for the ‘glaive of Cæsar’. But likewise no Christian should go the Essene route and reject the state in toto, in a world where functioning state or para-state structures are often the only thing standing between earth and a not-so-figurative hell for ‘the least of these’. No Christian should be a Sadducee and wish for a Sanhedrin to govern all aspects of our ritual and public life, figuring that this life and the next are of the same kind. On the other hand, no Christian should become a Zealot and seek to bring about the kingdom of heaven on earth by the ‘shortcut’ of messianic violence. Our Messiah came to conquer the kingdom of death, not to rule by it.

The Gospel message is not one of otherworldly comfort and consolation. It is a message of metaphysical, and therefore political, radicalism. We are called upon to behave as though not only our beloved friends and neighbours, but even our enemies, will partake in the Resurrection with us. We can, and we should, stand in solidarity with the rejected and crucified peoples of the world, just as our Lord was crucified between two ‘thieves’ (i.e. Zealots); but we are not to adopt the methods of Barabbas. Even in conditions of violence and war (which we are told will be with us even to the end), there is simply no room in the message of Christ for eliminationism of any sort. Because we are partaking in æternity, also: the anarchist temptation to ‘wipe the slate clean’ and start afresh, to recapture an Adamic existence in this world, is to be firmly resisted – even when that temptation is offered from an admirable purity of heart and a holy desire for heaven.

The intégristes are absolutely right that we (Christians especially) should not be easily able to discuss politics without thinking about our ultimate End. However, the most dangerous and most subtle temptation comes when we are clear about this fact, but less so about the nature – that is to say, personal character – of that End. And that is precisely the point on which the new intégristes are fuzzy, leading people like Ahmari to embrace personality-cult politics. This is why, in these discussions on the theopolitical turn that Americans are currently making – as in the Ahmari-French debate – I find my mind turning more and more toward specifically Russian apocalypticism.

Berdyaev had some rather backhanded praise for Vladimir Solovyov’s Tale of the Antichrist. Solovyov’s earlier suave, polished and meticulous ethical philosophy, which was essentially erotic poetry with a German inflection. On the other hand, Berdyaev commented that the Tale was not only dark and ominous, but carried a crude quality. It was sketch-like. It was left unfinished. I would personally add to this that it carries a distinct whiff of racist paranoia which should be neither condoned nor passed over in silence. But the Tale, as Berdyaev recognised, was perhaps one of the most enthralling and disquieting things Solovyov ever wrote. It represented Solovyov’s return to a distinctively-Russian style of apocalyptic, and it was all the more discomforting for the fact that it marked a turn away from Solovyov’s earlier optimistic winged visions of a liberal-theocratic utopia toward which human society was bending.

In the broad strokes, the Tale of the Antichrist narrates the life of the titular Antichrist, who is portrayed as a veteran, a wealthy capitalist and proud philanthropist, a ‘thinker, writer and public figure’ who possesses a keen and deeply spiritual mind. He is raised in an intellectual milieu of syncretism, born out of a devastating world war which pits Asia against the West. He is a practising ascetic; he opines convincingly on many of the world’s problems; he appeals at a deep root level to the human longing for spiritual fulfilment, creative freedom and unity. After his transforming rejection of Christ and his self-offering to the Evil One, he authors a book called The Open Way to Universal Peace and Prosperity, which, in Solovyov’s words:
united a noble respect for ancient traditions and symbols with a broad and daring radicalism in socio-political questions, joined a boundless freedom of thought with the most profound appreciation for everything mystical.
Using this book, the Antichrist proceeds to position himself as the leader of a ‘United States of Europe’, to deliver the human race everything it ever wanted – its spiritual longing for mystery and miracle, and not merely bread. All this, with the purpose of turning the human race towards him, and away from the person of Christ.

What is notable and indeed a bit disquieting about Solovyov’s Antichrist is that he can be read, as Berdyaev indeed interpreted it, as something of a self-criticism of his earlier work – or at least one possible interpretation of it. After Solovyov’s Antichrist is made President of Europe, he offers the world every possible physical need, every possible liberty, even every possible spiritual consolation. This includes the consolations of liberty, authority, tradition, asceticism, heroism, philosophy, scholastic accomplishment: but entirely without Christ. (What is further troubling about this story is how many Orthodox, Catholic and Protestant Christians are won over to his side by these explicitly spiritual blandishments.) What Solovyov’s Antichrist offers is, in fact, a reflection in significant part of Solovyov’s own vision of social-liberal theocracy: devoid of Christ.

It is this last feature which is most important. Christians of all traditions must be especially on guard against ideologies and social fixations, including even those fixations which don’t look like fixations (asceticism, tradition, authority, liberty et cetera), which are offered as ends in themselves instead of as reflections of the personal truth of Christ, who for the love of all died and rose again.

In America it is all too easy for Christians to make an idolatrous fixation out of liberty. This is in part because our national mythos has set up the false goddess of political liberty as a rival to Christ. But hæresies have a striking tendency to arise in opposing pairs. As the failures of liberalism highlighted by Ferrara become ever more apparent, the temptation of the opposite hæresy becomes stronger. Dostoevsky and Solovyov both intuited that the hæresy which opposes liberalism will be an anthropological hæresy which emphasises the spiritual potentials of man, which seeks to attend to his desires for mystery and miracle and hierarchy. It distresses me deeply that our current crop of intégristes – led by Ahmari and his cohort in this country, against the liberalism of French – have this anthropological fixation, rather than a devotion to the only Theánthrōpos.

05 November 2019

Holy Hierarch Kea, Bishop of Devon, and Holy Deacon Fili


Old Kea Church Tower, Cornwall

‘Remember, remember, the fifth of November…’ True, the Gunpowder Plot and Guy Fawkes are of course the common folk remembrances of the English on this day, and of course they’ve gotten a new lease on life thanks to that delightful mad genius of the graphic novel medium Alan Moore, but it sometimes escapes remembrance that in addition to being the date of the Gunpowder Plot, the fifth of November is also celebrated in southwest England and Brittany – and in the Holy Orthodox Church – as Saint Kea’s Day, the feast of a fifth-century Irish missionary hermit, later a bishop, who came to evangelise the coasts of Cornwall and Devon. We remember both Saint Kea today, and also his faithful helper and deacon Saint Fili who accompanied him.

This young monk from Ireland was apparently of noble birth and profoundly educated, but he gave up all his wealth to the poor and abandoned the life of a courtier for the life of a holy man when he was old enough to make the decision. The story of Saint Kea [also Quay in French, (Lan-te-)Ké or Ché in Breton, and Kay or Keyne in English] is strikingly similar to that of Saint Ia, the sister of Ss Euny and Erc. His hagiography opens much as Saint Ia’s does: watching from the southern shores of Ireland, seeing his brother-monks depart in their coracles for the heathen shores of Western Britain, and longing above all things that he might go with them. Burning with missionary zeal, he went to a certain promontory on the shore, which was a large boulder of granite, and prayed to God that if He willed it, Kea might go and preach the Gospel among the heathen Cornish.

And then the wonder happened. Just as with Saint Ia, a leaf floated by which by the power of her prayers was transformed into a coracle large enough for her to ride, so too with Saint Kea the very rock upon which he prostrated himself became broad and hollow. As the tide rose around the oblivious saint who was still lost in prayer, the waters of the sea lifted the granite rock off its perch on the shore and carried it out onto the open water. It floated as calmly and as lightly as any coracle made from hide. Saint Kea sprang to his feet upon seeing this, and in trembling awe cried aloud to God: ‘To Thee and only to Thee, my God, do I trust my soul!’

Saint Kea spent many days on the water in his unlikely granite boat, drifting hither and thither as the tides willed, or blown this way and that by the winds and waves. Despite not having food or drink with him, Saint Kea was sustained by his faith, and he knelt upon the rock three times a day and prayed fervently to God. At length, the faith of the saint brought him safely to the mouth of the Fal River on the southern coast of Cornwall, and he landed at a spot on the western shore at the confluence of the Fal and the Truro, which today still bears his name. It was here that he set up a hermitage and oratory for himself, which at length grew into a monastery. The only remains of this monastery, the Old Kea Church, are the ruins of a tower which still stands there.

There is a holy well that is dedicated to Saint Kea near the Old Kea Church. There are also place-names associated with Saint Kea in Devon – such as Landkey – which attest to his missionary presence there. It’s a near certainty, given the toponyms to this saint in Brittany, that he ended up across the Channel as well and founded churches there: like that at Saint-Quay-Portrieux on the Côtes d’Armor. He is said to have reposed in the Lord on the first Saturday in October, in Cléder in Finistère. He may also have had some connexion with Saint Gildas, who is said to have fashioned one or a set of the excellent Celtic bells for the saint.

Saint Kea is also associated with a younger British bishop, the ill-attested Saint Rumon of Tavistock (f.d. 30 August), who may have assisted Kea in founding his monastery after his landing. Saint Fili [also possibly Scofili] is an equally-obscure figure, though he is portrayed as a deacon assisting Saint Kea in the mediæval Cornish hagiographic tradition, and he is putatively the patron saint of Philleigh on the opposite shore of Truro from Kea, as well as Caerphilly in Wales. Local tradition has it that Saints Kea, Rumon and Fili worked to organise churches all around the Fal Estuary, and even fortified the area to defend against Saxon pirates. Even after the later conquests of Devon and Cornwall by Wessex, the kings of Wessex and England kept alive each local cultus of the Brythonic saints, and even revered them themselves – in much the same way that the Saxon Saint Ælfrǽd venerated the Cornish Saint Neot. Holy hierarch Kea, by whose faith even rocks were made to float, pray unto God that our souls might not meet shipwreck, but that we too may be saved!
Apolytikion to Saint Kea, Tone 1:

Thou wast unsparing in thy missionary labours
In Brittany and Cornwall, O Hierarch Kea.
As thou didst make the flame of the Orthodox Faith
Burn brightly in the face of defiant paganism,
Pray to God for us,
That we devote our lives to confronting the paganism of our times
For the glory of Christ's Kingdom and the salvation of men’s souls!


St Philleigh Church, Cornwall

04 November 2019

Holy Hierarch Byrnstán of Winchester, Bishop and Confessor


An engraving of Saint Byrnstán of Winchester ministering to the sick

Today in the Orthodox Church we commemorate a lesser-known saint of Winchester, the holy bishop Byrnstán [also Beornstán, Brynstan or Birnstan]. Byrnstán was the successor bishop to Bishop Friðestán and a spiritual son of the Frankish Byzantine abbot, Saint Grimbald of Bertin, who had been invited to English shores by the holy Ælfrǽd King.

Byrnstán was born sometime around the Danish invasion of England in 866, and was drawn toward the Benedictine life from a young age, but little else is known of his early life. He lived, flourished and died during the period of Danish dominance and rapine and well before the great Benedictine reformers in England, Dúnstán, Ósweald and Æþelwold (the last of whom did his utmost to encourage Byrnstán’s local cultus). This makes his holiness all the more noteworthy, given that he lived during a period when the Church in England was in a steep physical and spiritual decline.

Saint Byrnstán came to prominence during the reign of Æþelstán King, in whose retinue he served as a court chaplain. His name first appears in the record as a witness to the manumission of a slave named Ealdred. He continued as Bishop to serve at Æþelstán’s court, and witnessed several charters, but he was less prominent in his public office than his successors – notably Saint Ælfhéah.

Saint Byrnstán’s holiness was of the typical Benedictine type. That is to say: he was radically hospitable toward the poor. He founded the Hospital of Saint John in Winchester, which is still standing today and is owned and operated by Saint John’s Winchester: the single oldest continuously-operating charity in Great Britain. He made it a key point of his spiritual life to personally wash the feet of the poor folk who came to him, and to see to all of their other material needs. When he was done with this, he would go into the chapel to pray and would stay there for hours. He also said a Liturgy every day for the sake of the departed, and he would go out every night into the Cathedral graveyard and pray from the Psalter for those in the tombs. On one occasion he heard a great shout of ‘Amen’ coming from underground as he finished praying the Psalms, coming as it were from the mouths of a mighty army.

During these long periods of prayer, his attendant priests and deacons did not dare to intrude upon their bishop until he emerged from his chamber for his nightly vigil. On one cold November day in 934 the deacons did not see him emerge the entire day, and they did not think it odd until he failed to come out for his nightly prayers. They came in upon him and found Bishop Byrnstán lying on the floor, as though in a deep prostration, but without the breath of worldly life in him.

Bishop Byrnstán was known in his earthly life for his deep humility, as well as for his charity and his prayers for the dead. He had a reputation for piety in life, but no cultus arose for him until the days of Saint Æþelwold some decades later. In a dream, it is said, Byrnstán appeared to Æþelwold alongside Saint Berin and Saint Swíþhún. He told Æþelwold who his companions were, and likewise that he was honoured at the heavenly wedding banquet as their equal in honour. He also wished to be so remembered here on earth. As a result, Saint Æþelwold diligently encouraged his cultus, although Saint Swíþhún turned out to be the more enduringly popular local saint. Even so, as a saint who encouraged both prayer to the dead and almsgiving to the poor and sick, Saint Byrnstán deserves our own remembrance in love. Holy Father Byrnstán, pray unto Christ God for us sinners!


Hospital of St John, Winchester

03 November 2019

Venerable Gwenffrewi, Martyr-Abbess of Gwytherin


Saint Gwenffrewi of Gwytherin

The third of November is the feast-day of Gwenffrewi [or Winifred or Winefride] of Gwytherin, the niece of Saint Beuno. The beautiful only daughter of Beuno’s sister Gwenlo and her husband, the British chieftain Thewyth ap Eliud of Tegeingl in northern Wales, Saint Gwenffrewi was martyred for refusing the hand of a proud and violent suitor, and then raised to life again by the power of Christ through the wonderworking prayers of her uncle.

Gwenffrewi was born sometime in the early 600s. It seems reasonable to assume that she was still a young woman when Beuno was already in exile from the court of Selyf ‘the Battle-Serpent’ ap Cynan who came to power in 610 and ruled until 616, which would probably place her date of birth sometime in the late 600s, to possibly as late as 613. However, what is known is that upon his arrival at his kinsman Thewyth’s home, he offered to tutor Gwenffrewi, who was a bright and obedient girl. For this service, Thewyth offered Saint Beuno the church at Abeluyc – now Treffynnon or Holywell. On this land, in a place called the Valley of Sechnant, at a chapel he built for himself, Holy Father Beuno taught young Gwenffrewi in all subjects. From him she learned to love Christ and to prise holiness, and dedicated herself to becoming a nun. She took from him the veil in secret, though with the blessing of her father and mother.

On one Lord ’s Day when Saint Beuno was celebrating the Liturgy, Gwenffrewi was staying at home when a young British lordling named Caradog ap Alaog Pennarlag came riding by. He saw her through the open doorway and was immediately stricken with a fierce lust to possess her. He called to her for a drink of water, saying he was thirsty, but he was already formulating an evil intent against her. When the kindly Gwenffrewi invited him into the house, he made an advance which was at once rejected, she having already taken vows of chastity. He then grabbed her and attempted to force himself on her, and thus she fled from the house up toward the church.

Fearing she would expose him, Caradog took to his horse and rode after her. He overtook her, and as she was running up the steps of the church he drew his sword and struck her on the neck, beheading her. Saint Beuno, who had been celebrating the Liturgy within the Church, came outside and found Caradog still over his niece’s headless body, holding the bloody sword – clearly unrepentant of what he had done. Enraged at the violence and sacrilege of the young prince, Saint Beuno issued forth a terrible curse, and at once Caradog’s flesh melted from his bones like water and the earth swallowed him whole.

Beuno then turned about and told his flock about Gwenffrewi’s blameless chastity and her desire to become a nun. He took up his martyred niece’s head and attached it to her shoulders. Where Gwenffrewi’s head had fallen, there sprang up at once a spring of fresh water – this is St Winefride’s Well at Holywell, which can still be found there. Once he had done this, he asked the people’s prayers for Gwenffrewi. As the townsfolk prayed with Saint Beuno, Saint Gwenffrewi arise from the dead through their prayers, just as Jairus’s daughter who was thought to be dead. But forever thereafter Gwenffrewi bore a thin red scar all the way around her neck where it had been sliced through by Caradog’s sword.

Saint Gwenffrewi took instruction from Father Beuno to remain cloistered at Treffynnon, as it was now known. She gathered to her eleven other young women of good character and they all took vows together with Gwenffrewi, who became their abbess. Saint Beuno would continue his travels westward into Ireland, but Saint Gwenffrewi and her nuns would always furnish him forth with handiwork of their own, and that of excellent craftsmanship, for him to use in the Liturgy.

Saint Gwenffrewi was instrumental in establishing within Wales and within the Celtic tradition of Christianity, the regular common life of the cloister over-against the hitherto common custom of the eremitical life. From her own experience and out of sympathy for her sister-nuns, she felt that there was both spiritual and physical safety to be had in numbers, and also that cloisters for women could serve as shelter for women who had suffered abuse in their own homes or who desired sanctuary for other reasons. Gwenffrewi made a pilgrimage to Rome, and then called a gathering of women religious from her own monastic home upon her return. Thereafter, she began promoting her ideas throughout the Welsh north. It wasn’t until she met Saint Eleri [i.e. Hilarion] of Gwytherin that she found a receptive audience – the other men she met preferred the hermit’s cell to the monastic brotherhood. However, with the help of Saint Eleri and his mother Saint Tenoi she established a double monastery in Gwytherin, where she served the rest of her life – first as a nun under Abbess Tenoi, and then succeeding her as abbess.

When she reposed a second time on the third of November, 660, she was given an honourable Christian burial in the monastic cemetery. Her relics would be translated in 1136 to a magnificent shrine in Shrewsbury Abbey, on the orders of Abbot Herebert of that house. The translation would be carried out by the Norman prior of that house, Robert Pennant, who would write Gwenffrewi’s Vita. (This cross-border translation provides the factual basis for the historical fiction / murder mystery novel by Edith Pargeter, A Morbid Taste for Bones – the first of her Chronicles of Brother Cadfael. Saint Gwenffrewi’s feast day provides the backdrop for several of the other novels in the series, and her intercessions occasionally make themselves felt in the life of the eponymous monk.)

Saint Gwenffrewi and her family were all very proudly and very steadfastly British. There were those among her kin who were eager and sanguinary defenders of their lands against the English. However, she has bridged the two nations and their religious customs in more ways than one. She was a significant influence on the Celtic church in creating an option for the common life and a rule of community, rather than the hermitage. She was notably an advocate for women’s physical security and voice within the Celtic church. She bestowed her blessings not only upon one nation alone, but on both where her cultus prevailed. She has been considered, therefore, as much an English saint as a Welsh one. Holy Mother Gwenffrewi, pure-minded martyr and gentle tutor of nuns, pray unto Christ our God to save our souls!
Desiring union with the eternal Bridegroom alone, O pious Gwenffrewi,
Thou didst spurn the advances of the arrogant prince,
Who, thwarted in his vile lust, struck off thy holy head with his sword.
But thy pure body was by a miracle of God
Restored to life at the prayers of the holy Beuno.
Wherefore, thou didst consecrate thyself wholly to the service of thy Lord;
And having now joined the choirs of virgins and martyrs on high,
Thou prayest unceasingly that He grant grace and salvation
to those who honor thy holy memory with love.

Venerable Gwyddfarch, Abbot of Meifod


Saints Gwyddfarch and Tysilio

The third of November is the feast-day of Saint Gwyddfarch of Welshpool and Meifod, the spiritual father of Saint Tysilio. Much of what we know about this saint comes from the tradition of his pupil, whose holy life bears witness to the holiness of his master.

In fact, little is known about the early life of Saint Gwyddfarch. He himself was a pupil of Saint Llywellyn of Welshpool. Llywellyn established a mission caring for the Christian Briton refugees who were fleeing westward from the heathen Angles, Saxons and Jutes who had landed on Great Britain at the invitation of Vortigern. These refugees were largely arriving from Salop (the shire around Shrewsbury), particularly from the town of Wroxeter.

Setting out from Welshpool, Gwyddfarch found a desert place in the northeast of Wales – in Powys. He constructed his cell atop a solitary, high sloping hill overlooking the Afon Efyrnwy (nowadays Llyn Efyrnwy). The hill itself was named for Saint Gwyddfarch – Moel yr Ancr, the ‘Hill of the Anchorite’ – and it was in this cell on the hill that Gwyddfarch lived the rest of his life and reposed in the Lord, and also where Saint Tysilio began his vocation as a monk and hermit himself. Today it is apparently a scenic spot; however, in Gwyddfarch’s own day Moel yr Ancr was a hard, cold, wooded area, and was home to many wolves and other wild beasts.

Saint Gwyddfarch was the one who gave sanctuary and shelter to Saint Tysilio when he came fleeing his father’s wrath; and he was also the one who guided Tysilio on his desired path of becoming a monk. He therefore deserves no small part of the credit for Tysilio’s Christlike gentleness, heroic resolve in the face of temptations, and willingness to go to where folk are in greatest need – even as far afield from his own home as the shores of Brittany. Venerable Gwyddfarch, helper of the bereaved, hermit and teacher of saints, pray to Christ our God for us sinners!

02 November 2019

Holy Hierarch Erc mac Dega, Bishop of Slane


Hill of Slane, Ireland

The second of November in the Holy Orthodox Church is the feast-day of Saint Erc of Slane, an Irish bishop who has significant connexions with Cornwall. A former druid and a convert of Saint Padrig the Enlightener, he was one of Ireland’s foremost missionary saints. He was also the elder brother of Saint Euny and Saint Ia of Cornwall, and accompanied them to that part of Britain.

Saint Erc [also in Cornish Erth, in Welsh Urith, sometimes incorrectly Herygh] was born in Ireland, most likely in Munster, sometime around the turn of the fifth century. He was a druid – a pagan priest – and a retainer in the employ of King Lóegaire mac Néill. It so happened that Saint Padrig was celebrating, together with his Christian converts, the Lord’s Pascha on the same night as the king’s court was celebrating Beltane. There was at that time a taboo on lighting any fire within a set distance from the king’s court, at any time that night before the king’s Beltane bonfire was lit. The Holy Fire of Saint Padrig’s Paschal Liturgy, however, was lit on high and could be seen throughout Tara, and it was brought forth before the King’s bonfire could be lit.

King Lóegaire was amazed at the brazenness of whomever could be flouting the law, and inquired of his closest advisors who might be doing it. The druids all told him that unless this fire was extinguished, his kingdom would be overthrown. A Herodian fear gripped the heart of the king, and he moved at once in force to quench the fire of Christ and to exterminate its bearers. The king went with his retainers and his chief druids, and set himself up a certain distance away from Padrig’s Paschal procession, and commanded that Padrig be brought forward to answer for what he had done. He also arranged it so that none of his retainers were to give Saint Padrig any mark of recognition or respect. However, Erc, who was among the retainers, as soon as he saw Saint Padrig, was moved to stand and hail the saint. Saint Padrig in turn blessed him, and from that point forward Saint Erc was a believer in Christ.

This was one of Saint Padrig’s many confrontations with worldly authority during his life, and the beginning of a long struggle between Padrig and Lóegaire which ended in Lóegaire’s baptism. For Saint Erc, however, this was also the beginning of a mission in which he would suffer like Paul on behalf of those who did not believe. Padrig made Erc at once a bishop of that place where they met, which was the hill of Slane. There, with Saint Padrig’s help, Erc established a church, a monastery and a school that would stand for the next six hundred years. This was the centre of his missionary work in Ireland. It was said that from here he tutored Saint Breandán of Clonfert.

Saint Padrig and Saint Breandán were not the only great Irish saints Erc was close to in life. He was also particularly fond of Saint Brigid of Kildare, for whose holiness, compassion and abilities Erc early formed the very highest of opinions. Saint Padrig saw Erc’s abilities in holding sway over a bishopric even from within his monastery, and sent him into Kerry, Clare and Connaught. Here Saint Erc taught the Gospel, healed the sick, aided the poor and baptised many new believers in Christ. By the end of his life, Saint Padrig had made Saint Erc responsible for most of the territory which is now included in the region of Munster.

Assuming Saint Erc to have been the same person as the Cornish Saint Erth, he also kept his brother Euny company in his voyage to Cornwall, and Saint Ia soon followed after them in her coracle made from a single leaf by the power of her prayers, only to reach the other shore before them. Saint Erc is credited with founding St Erth’s Church in the town of the same name in Cornwall, standing some four miles distant from St Ives, where his holy sister made her anchorage. Toward the end of his life, however, Saint Erc returned to Ireland and to Slane, and spent the remainder of his years in a solitary hermitage at the hill of Slane. This is where he reposed in the Lord on the second of November in the year 512. His feast day is kept on this day in Ireland as well as in the Moscow Patriarchate, where he is on the calendar of saints. Cornwall remembers St Erth on the thirty-first of October. Holy hierarch Erc, selfless and righteous confessor among the Irish and Cornish people, pray unto Christ our God for our salvation!
Apolytikion for Saint Erc, Tone 1:

Even in the darkness of heathendom,
Thou didst recognise the God-given authority of Ireland’s Enlightener,
O Hierarch Erc, and wast baptised at his hands!
Wherefore we beseech thee,
Pray to Christ our God that being blessed with the virtue of humility
We may be found worthy of æternal salvation.


St Erth’s Church, St Erth, Cornwall

01 November 2019

Venerable Cadfan, Abbot of Bardsey


Eglwys Sant Cadfan, Tywyn, Gwynedd

The first of November is, in the Orthodox Church, the feast day of Saint Cadfan, the sixth-century missionary and founder of Ynys Enlli, or Bardsey, the isle of 20,000 saints in the west of Wales. One of Wales’s most celebrated hermits, Saint Cadfan still enjoys a thriving cultus in the Western churches, particularly in the Finistère and Côtes d’Armor départements of Brittany.

Saint Cadfan was a Breton himself, actually. Born to Saint Gwen Teirbron by her short-lived first husband Eneas (according to the Welsh tradition rather than the French one), he established a couple of churches in his homeland, at Poullan-sur-Mer and the Côtes d’Armor. Shortly after this, he left Brittany to preach Christ in Wales, in the company of the nine sons of the Breton prince Ithel Hael who were all his disciples. These were the saints Baglan, Flewyn, Gredifael, Tanwg, Twrog, Tegai, Trillo, Tecwyn and Llechid. Once in Wales he founded monastic churches at Tywyn in Gwynedd – which is still standing and which watches over Saint Cadfan’s holy well – and Llangadfan in Powys. Only after this did Cadfan settle in Ynys Enlli.

Ynys Enlli would become one of the holiest sites in Western Christendom owing to the sincere witness to Christ of Saint Cadfan and his followers. It is not called the ‘Isle of 20,000 Saints’ without cause, for there many holy monks would make their rest. Even Saint Dyfrig and Saint Deiniol would be buried there. In the High Middle Ages it was said that three pilgrimages to Ynys Enlli was equivalent to one pilgrimage to Rome. Many wonders for sick and sorrowing folk were wrought upon Ynys Enlli, over the hallowed relics of the holy monks who lived and died there.

Saint Cadfan ruled his abbatial community on Ynys Enlli for the next twenty-six years. He made his confessions to another holy man living nearby, a certain Saint Hywyn. He made numerous missionary voyages into the Welsh mainland, healing the sick and aiding the poor. He reposed in the Lord in Ynys Enlli on the first of November, sometime late in the sixth century. However, his relics were translated to Llandaff Cathedral some hundred years later. All three major sites which were hallowed to Christ by Saint Cadfan – Tywyn, Ynys Enlli, Llandaff – were the sites of mass pilgrimages in the centuries to come, drawn by their great love of the monastic saint, and by his great love for Christ and for the poor. Holy father Cadfan, pray unto Christ our God that our souls may be saved!
Leaving thy native Brittany for the love of Christ, O Father Cadfan,
Thou dost teach us not to love places or things more than Him.
Wherefore, O holy one, intercede for us
That we may be faithful to our calling
And found worthy of great mercy!


Ynys Enlli