14 October 2019

Harold II Godwineson, King of England


An unofficial icon of Harold Godwineson

Private venerations of Harold, the last of the Old English kings in the British Isles, have been growing in popularity among Orthodox Christians who venerate the pre-Schismatic saints of Old England. Personally, I happen to be among them. In my view, Harold was at the very least a Passion-Bearer, having fought in a just cause and having subsequently been killed and mutilated for political reasons.

Six years ago, on the Old Calendar anniversary of the fateful Battle of Hastings, I wrote this blog post about the sanctity of Harold. There are parts of it now that I find a bit historically naïve – in particular my reliance on Vladimir Moss. But other than that, I still feel it’s a thesis that holds up.
Harold II of England, son of Earl Godwin of Wessex and the last of the Saxon Kings, was on this day nine hundred forty-seven years ago martyred in battle at Hastings by the conquering Norman army of William the Bastard. Thus began what has come to be known as the ‘Norman yoke’ – a memory of an England whose traditional language and traditional folkways were repressed by the imposition of foreign laws and a continental nobility. The Norman yoke was no fiction, and they wasted no time in laying it upon Saxon shoulders: within three years of King Harold’s death they had laid waste to the entire north of England and reduced it to starvation and beggary. Within twenty, they had effected a massive upward concentration of wealth, through force consolidated the holdings of over 4,000 Saxon thanes and earls into the hands of some 200 Norman lords, clamped down tight on minting to ensure their control over the developing monetary economy, introduced a more rigid form of feudal administration, introduced usury, and took their payment by bleeding off the English economy to finance infrastructure in Normandy. The common English folkways crushed and driven underground in the aftermath of King Harold’s death still found expression through, for example, the popular mediaeval legend of Robin Hood, who championed simple folk and the commons against a ravening nobility.

Regrettably, during the Reformation and through the English Civil War, the ‘Norman yoke’ came to take on an anti-Catholic and anti-apostolic flavour as English Protestant nationalists attempted to marshal the Saxon heritage to their cause. In actuality, the deep irony of the ‘Norman yoke’ legend being invoked by the radical Calvinist Roundheads, was that their ‘reformed’ heresy was every bit as much a legalistic, repressive and regicidal Norman import as William the Bastard had been! (Jean Chauvin hailed from Picardie.) And, of course, in the end, those same English Protestants who bemoaned the ‘Norman yoke’ gladly welcomed with open arms yet another continental invader named William, who harrowed the Scottish, Irish and northern English every bit as brutally as his eponym had harrowed the Saxons.

In truth, Old England was not heterodox in any way, even if there was a backsliding in the moral life of the Church its twilight years. Much,
much less were they wont to treat their kings with the dishonour their heretical offspring shew theirs, the doom of Saint King Edward the Martyr not withstanding. (Even that regicide was treated as a hitherto unheard-of and nigh unforgivable crime.) And, as Archpriest Andrew Phillips put it: ‘England of the Old English with all its faults was also a land of hallowed bishops and holy kings, of martyr-priests and confessors, of noble princes and princesses, saintly abbesses and humble cowherds, meek hermits and lowly monks, righteous families and silent nuns, faithful queens and gentle abbots, who hallowed it from North to South and East to West’. Just as the English people were generally loyal to their own kings, the English Church and people were highly loyal to Rome in all things beginning with St Gregory the Great and St Augustine of Canterbury. But, as Vladimir Moss put it in his book, The Fall of Orthodox England, ‘the “Romanity” to which the English were so devoted was not the Franco-Latin Catholicism of the later Middle Ages. Rather, it was the Greco-Roman Romanitas or Ρωμιοσύνη of Orthodox Catholicism’…

Harold himself should be considered here. He was, by all accounts, a good king and a good man: ‘wise, patient, merciful, courageous, temperate and prudent in character’. He repeatedly showed courage, loyalty and compassion - he saved two men from quicksand when he was a hostage of the Normans. In the wake of the death of St King Edward the Confessor, he ascended to the throne without any opposition from the Saxon
witan. Vladimir Moss cites Florence of Worcester’s glowing account of his short reign:
[Harold] immediately began to abolish unjust laws and to make good ones; to patronize churches and monasteries; to pay particular reverence to bishops, abbots, monks and clerics; and to show himself pious, humble and affable to all good men. But he treated malefactors with great severity, and gave general orders to his earls, ealdormen, sheriffs and thegns to imprison all thieves, robbers and disturbances of the kingdom. He laboured in his own person by sea and by land for the protection of his realm.
Again, there are parts of this that I could bolster by appeal to sources other than Moss, now, and I would not overstress the Varangian part of that thesis. Instead, I would draw attention to the saints of the Old English church who were not only versed in Greek literature both classic and contemporary, but also to those who studied, admired and did their best to emulate the spiritual traditions of Antioch, Palestine and Alexandria. That part aside, there does seem to be valid grounds for individual Orthodox to include Harold King in their personal venerations, awaiting an official glorification. Harold, passion-bearing king of blessed memory, we ask your prayers!

2 comments:

  1. Very nice!
    In my humble opinion, battle of Hastings is very alike battle of Kosovo field in Serbia in 1389
    Where our king Lazar died defending Orthodox Serbia against the Ottomans and lost his head but got Kingdom of Heaven just like Harold
    And the invaders in both cases began to brutally capture defeated countries

    ReplyDelete
  2. Wonderful job
    Have you written any posts about Saint Edmund?

    ReplyDelete